Makeup Review: Pencil Eyeliner

PENCIL EYE LINERS

1.  MAC 

• On the upper eye lid, it was able to hold its own even without an eyeshadow primer; but on the lower lid,  it's another story
• Used on my inner upper waterline, needless to say I had raccoon eyes after a couple of hours  

     2.  Benefit Bad Gal Liner Waterproof 

• this is very creamy so it's very easy to apply and is double ended but I never used the smudger because I find that it always hurts when I do
• actually stayed on my waterline for a few hours (in an air-conditioned room)

     3.  Styli-style Liquid Eyeliner

• I have the short and pointy tip and I find that this is difficult to use when you want to create a very fine line
• They have different tips you can choose from (just like a pentel pen)
• I have the Blackest Black but I find that it's not a solid black until you apply a second layer

     4. Elizabeth Arden Eye Pencil

• This pencil came in a set, and it is the regular eye pencil
• If you want an eyeliner that smudges, this is the liner you're looking for
• Very creamy